Cocoa Amore: Leicester’s Chocolate Shop
Tucked away on Silver Street in Leicester’s Old Town Lanes, Cocoa Amore has been delighting chocolate lovers for more than a decade.
Step inside and you’ll find handmade chocolates, rich hot chocolates and, upstairs, a workshop where visitors roll up their sleeves and make their own. It’s no wonder so many regulars simply call it “Leicester’s chocolate shop”.
We had the absolute pleasure of sitting down with founder and owner Pete Gardner, the self-taught chocolatier behind it all. Pete’s story doesn’t begin in a pastry kitchen. He left school and went straight into Leicestershire’s pubs and nightclubs in 1998, becoming an assistant manager in Hinckley before he turned 19. He later took on a pub franchise of his own and later after a year and moved back to Loughborough to start something new.
Determined to do something more creative than pouring pints, Pete noticed that Loughborough’s busy student town centre had plenty of bars and cafés but only one chocolate shop, a Thorntons. He taught himself chocolate-making through YouTube videos and books picked up from a charity shop. With just £100, he put together a business plan and secured a loan to open his first chocolate shop in Loughborough, Chocolate Alchemy.
When Leicester’s newly refurbished Silver Arcade was looking for tenants in 2013, Pete was invited to open there. Having sold his Loughborough business, he started afresh with a new name, and on 17 October 2013, Cocoa Amore opened its doors as one of the first businesses in the arcade. The name means “cocoa love”, which is why the logo is a cocoa pod opened up into the shape of a heart.
Those early days were far from glamorous. Pete made, taught and sold everything from a 500 sq ft unit on the arcade’s second floor, and had to borrow a chocolate tank because his own hadn’t arrived in time. But loyal customers followed him from Loughborough, and recognition came quickly. Within about a year, Pete had been invited to showcase his chocolate at a Christmas market in Downing Street, named one of the top 20 small shops in the country, and shortlisted for Micro Entrepreneur of the Year.
By 2015, Cocoa Amore had outgrown the arcade and moved to a derelict building at 34 Silver Street, taking on its four floors one at a time as the business grew. There was one more reason Pete chose it: the shop window faces north. He checks every potential location with a compass, because a north-facing window keeps the sun off the chocolate all year round.
What makes Cocoa Amore different is its focus on experience. Pete saw that most chocolate shops either simply sold boxed products from a manufacturer or were highly specialised, expensive boutiques. He wanted something in between: real chocolate at a fair price, with the theatre of a chocolatier at work and the chance to learn why good chocolate is worth it.
“I’ve built my business the wrong way round, really,” Pete said. “I built it around customer service and experience first and then added the chocolate skills.”
That approach has clearly paid off. In 2021, Cadbury chose Cocoa Amore as one of just six independent chocolatiers across the country for its national For the Love of Chocolate campaign, representing the Midlands.
Today, the workshops are what Cocoa Amore is best known for, welcoming 50 to 60 people a week on average, with some visitors travelling from as far as London. In the run-up to Christmas, around 650 spaces are available on the festive Christmas wreath workshops, which run until 23 December. After that, the shop closes until January so the team can spend the holidays at home.
The hot chocolates are another firm favourite, and the latest creations to catch on are little chocolate shots, served in cups made in-house and finished with different toppings. Pete is always experimenting, and when we visited, he was perfecting a vegan marshmallow foam that can be piped onto a hot chocolate and finished with a blowtorch.

Inclusivity is close to Pete’s heart, too. As a small kitchen can’t be completely nut-free, the shop stocks chocolates from fellow maker Mr Popples, which are free from all 14 major allergens, alongside lower-sugar options. Cocoa Amore also caters for festivals across Leicester’s communities, and this year, for the first time, Eid outsold Valentine’s Day. Next year, Pete plans to introduce chocolates inspired by Indian sweets in time for Diwali.
“Chocolate should be for everyone,” he said.
Pete works in the business six days a week, moving between the kitchen, the shop floor and the workshop, and regulars know him by name. He admits he’s terrible with names, but he can match a face to a drink. One of his favourite moments is seeing customers grow up alongside the business. Children who once came to birthday party workshops at 11 or 12 have returned a decade later to order chocolate favours for their weddings.
Cocoa Amore is also a proud collaborator with other Leicester businesses, from creating chocolates for The Exchange’s winter menu to helping local restaurants with chocolate desserts. For Pete, independents like these are what make the city special.
“No other city has a Cocoa Amore” he said. “We should be promoting Leicester for all these special businesses you can’t get anywhere else.”
Looking ahead, Pete dreams of turning Cocoa Amore into a national brand that Leicester can be proud of, built on the model he created here. He has also launched BABAO CACAO, a separate venture that turns the cacao fruit usually thrown away in chocolate-making into cacao fruit water, seltzers and husk teas, now available through a national distributor.
Whether you’re a chocolate lover, looking for a unique gift or after a memorable experience, head down to Cocoa Amore at Silver Street, Leicester. The shop is open Tuesday to Saturday, 10am – 5pm, and workshops can be booked online at cocoa-amore.co.uk. Pop in, try something new and discover why Leicester calls it their chocolate shop.